The Value of a Review (and for who?)

tripadvisor-logoBeing in Holland for our annual Meet the Parents (and friends) Trip earlier this month we got a request to write a review about the hotel that we had been staying in. As we ask our guests to do the same it was time to return to favour to society and so I did. Being at it, the eternal question crept up again “what happens with these reviews”? What do hotels and restaurants do with them (how can we improve)? Or is it -just – useful for informing future potential guests?

Here at Cortijo El Guarda we try to learn from guest remarks, both on site or later through their reviews, sometimes easier than in other situations. Since I have been working in the Client Satisfaction Arena for quite some years the subject always has interested me. I learned that it only makes sense to ask guests for their input if you are willing to improve; otherwise they will just stop giving you feedback. But that’s – in first instance – all related to us business owners.

How about you, our guests? How trustworthy are reviews?  I recently was contacted by a company that provides content and marketing services to hotels and restaurants across the globe. One of the services that they offer is “Tripadvisor and third party reviews”, so for USD 20 a property can get a review posted on Tripadvisor. Needless to these reviews are done by people that have never even visited the place. I have seen many complaints from property owners about bad reviews from people who never stayed, or even disgruntled neighbors and these can be almost impossible to remove. While this is due to a weakness in the Tripadvisor system, I don’t fault Tripadvisor for it.

How to recognise fake reviews? One thing I would be suspicious of when reading property reviews, would be a number of new good reviews, if the general history for the property has been neutral to negative. One thing I would especially recommend when looking for lodgings, and something I always do, is to look for reviews on booking sites as well. Reviews that are left on sites like can only be left if the person actually booked through the site and stayed at the property. So these reviews combined with those you may find on sites like Trip Advisor should give you a fairly good idea of what an accommodation may really be like.

So back to us; what did we learned from you last year? This winter we put an extra window in a room that a few guests found a bit too darkish, an extra door to create a bit more silence in another room and installed a generator to deal with the occasional Spanish rural power breaks, we appreciate your feedback and keep on listening.


About The El Guarda Posts

We are a Dutch couple - Miranda and Hans - that has after having searched for a small hotel to buy in several countries around the world we came across El Guarda and fell in love with it straight away. We would love to share our excitement for the place and its surroundings with our guests and invite you to stay with us for some days when travelling through gorgeous Andalucía.
This entry was posted in Us and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to The Value of a Review (and for who?)

  1. Pingback: My View on Reviews | The El Guarda Posts

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s